Head to Head
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/08 14:00 | Keighley v Newcastle Thunder | L | 22-32 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/05/19 14:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Keighley | L | 40-12 |
| RFL 1895 Cup | 2019/05/04 13:30 | Newcastle Thunder v Keighley | L | 38-12 |
| RFL League 1 | 2018/08/12 14:00 | Keighley v Newcastle Thunder | W | 24-16 |
| RFL League 1 | 2018/04/22 13:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Keighley | W | 14-34 |
| RFL League 1 | 2017/09/03 14:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Keighley | L | 34-8 |
| RFL League 1 | 2017/06/11 14:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Keighley | L | 36-12 |
| RFL League 1 | 2016/06/04 17:00 | Keighley v Newcastle Thunder | W | 36-14 |
Home History
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/08 14:00 | Keighley v Newcastle Thunder | L | 22-32 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/01 14:00 | Doncaster v Keighley | L | 48-12 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/08/18 14:00 | Keighley v Whitehaven | L | 19-48 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/08/10 17:00 | Keighley v Hunslet | L | 10-32 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/08/04 14:00 | Coventry v Keighley | W | 20-46 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/07/21 14:00 | Workington v Keighley | L | 52-4 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/07/14 14:00 | Keighley v West Wales Raiders | W | 50-18 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/06/30 13:30 | North Wales Crusaders v Keighley | L | 14-6 |
Away History
| RFL League 1 | 2019/10/06 14:00 | Oldham v Newcastle Thunder | L | 18-14 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/29 11:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Doncaster | W | 34-4 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/22 15:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Workington | W | 38-18 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/15 13:30 | Newcastle Thunder v Doncaster | L | 6-20 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/08 14:00 | Keighley v Newcastle Thunder | W | 22-32 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/09/01 14:00 | Newcastle Thunder v North Wales Crusaders | W | 46-22 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/08/18 14:00 | Newcastle Thunder v Coventry | W | 88-6 |
| RFL League 1 | 2019/08/11 14:00 | Oldham v Newcastle Thunder | L | 28-20 |