Head to Head
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/04 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Erie Commodores | L | 5-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2019/07/05 23:00 | Erie Commodores v FC Buffalo | D | 2-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2019/06/07 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Erie Commodores | L | 2-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2018/06/29 23:05 | FC Buffalo v Erie Commodores | W | 0-4 |
Home History
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/25 19:00 | Syracuse v Erie Commodores | D | 0-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/20 21:00 | Rochester Lancers v Erie Commodores | W | 2-5 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/13 18:00 | Erie Commodores v Syracuse | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/11 23:00 | SC Cleveland v Erie Commodores | L | 3-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/06 18:00 | Erie Commodores v Rochester Lancers | L | 0-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/04 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Erie Commodores | L | 5-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/05/29 23:00 | Erie Commodores v Pittsburgh Hotspurs | L | 0-1 |
| USA NPSL Members Cup | 2020/07/29 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Pittsburgh Hotspurs | L | 0-3 |
Away History
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/27 20:00 | SC Cleveland v FC Buffalo | L | 3-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/19 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Pittsburgh Hotspurs | L | 1-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/13 18:00 | FC Buffalo v SC Cleveland | L | 1-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/11 23:00 | Pittsburgh Hotspurs v FC Buffalo | L | 2-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/06/04 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Erie Commodores | W | 5-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/05/28 23:00 | FC Buffalo v Syracuse | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2021/05/23 21:00 | Rochester Lancers v FC Buffalo | W | 0-3 |
| USA NISA Independent Cup | 2020/08/02 19:00 | Detroit City FC v FC Buffalo | L | 3-0 |