Head to Head
| Players Championship 2 2021 | 2021/02/26 16:00 | Michael Smith v Josh Payne | 5-6 |
| BDO World Championship 2019 | 2017/04/30 13:59 | Michael Smith v Josh Payne | 5-2 |
Home History
| European Championship 2021 | 2021/10/15 20:25 | Michael Smith v Ryan Searle | 5-6 |
| World Grand Prix 2021 | 2021/10/03 20:45 | Gerwyn Price v Michael Smith | 2-0 |
| European Tour 2 2021 | 2021/09/25 13:45 | Michael Smith v Simon Whitlock | 2-6 |
| European Tour 1 2021 | 2021/09/05 20:40 | Gerwyn Price v Michael Smith | 8-2 |
| European Tour 1 2021 | 2021/09/05 19:55 | Jose De Sousa v Michael Smith | 5-7 |
| European Tour 1 2021 | 2021/09/05 18:40 | Peter Wright v Michael Smith | 2-6 |
| European Tour 1 2021 | 2021/09/05 14:30 | Michael Smith v Keane Barry | 6-1 |
| European Tour 1 2021 | 2021/09/04 20:45 | Michael Smith v John Michael | 6-3 |
Away History
| Players Championship 20 2021 | 2021/07/08 11:20 | Josh Payne v Alan Soutar | 3-6 |
| Players Championship 17 2021 | 2021/07/05 14:20 | Josh Payne v Andy Hamilton | 6-4 |
| Players Championship 11 2021 | 2021/04/26 12:30 | Josh Payne v Joe Murnan | 6-5 |
| Players Championship 8 2021 | 2021/03/19 12:25 | Josh Payne v Boris Krcmar | 3-6 |
| Players Championship 6 2021 | 2021/03/17 16:20 | Niels Zonneveld v Josh Payne | 6-4 |
| PDC UK Open 2021 | 2021/03/05 15:20 | Rowby-John Rodriguez v Josh Payne | 6-5 |
| Players Championship 4 2021 | 2021/02/28 14:25 | Ryan Searle v Josh Payne | 6-4 |
| Players Championship 2 2021 | 2021/02/26 16:00 | Michael Smith v Josh Payne | 5-6 |