Head to Head
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 21:40 | Paul Nicholson v Andy Jenkins | 3-4 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/06/20 13:05 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 5-3 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/06/18 13:05 | Paul Nicholson v Andy Jenkins | 3-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/06/16 13:05 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 2-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/25 11:15 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 5-2 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/24 10:25 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 4-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/21 11:00 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 5-4 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/20 10:00 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 4-5 |
Home History
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 22:55 | Wes Newton v Andy Jenkins | 2-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 22:05 | Andy Jenkins v Richie Howson | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 21:25 | Tony O'Shea v Andy Jenkins | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 00:20 | Andy Jenkins v Tony O'Shea | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 23:35 | Richie Howson v Andy Jenkins | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 22:50 | Andy Jenkins v Wes Newton | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 21:40 | Paul Nicholson v Andy Jenkins | 3-4 |
| Online Live League Week 5 2022 | 2022/08/28 00:00 | Andy Jenkins v Robert Thornton | 1-4 |
Away History
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 23:15 | Paul Nicholson v Richie Howson | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 22:25 | Paul Nicholson v Tony O'Shea | 4-3 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/14 21:45 | Wes Newton v Paul Nicholson | 4-2 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 23:50 | Paul Nicholson v Wes Newton | 2-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 23:15 | Tony O'Shea v Paul Nicholson | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 22:25 | Richie Howson v Paul Nicholson | 4-2 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2022 | 2022/10/13 21:40 | Paul Nicholson v Andy Jenkins | 3-4 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/06/27 13:55 | Stephen Burton v Paul Nicholson | 5-3 |