Head to Head
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/09 19:15 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 6-3 |
| NZ Darts Masters 2022 | 2022/08/27 09:30 | Jonny Clayton v Michael Smith | 7-5 |
| New South Wales Darts Masters 2022 | 2022/08/20 10:25 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 4-6 |
| Players Championship 20 2022 | 2022/07/10 14:20 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 5-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/05/26 21:15 | Jonny Clayton v Michael Smith | 3-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/05/19 20:10 | Jonny Clayton v Michael Smith | 6-4 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/05/12 19:05 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 6-5 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/04/28 20:25 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 4-6 |
Home History
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/16 20:20 | Gerwyn Price v Michael Smith | 3-6 |
| Players Championship 2 2023 | 2023/02/12 16:55 | Brendan Dolan v Michael Smith | 6-3 |
| Players Championship 2 2023 | 2023/02/12 13:50 | Michael Smith v Jose Justicia | 6-5 |
| Players Championship 1 | 2023/02/11 16:25 | Michael Smith v Jamie Hughes | 3-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/09 21:20 | Michael Smith v Nathan Aspinall | 4-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/09 19:15 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 6-3 |
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/02 19:40 | Michael Smith v Michael van Gerwen | 3-6 |
| The Masters 2023 | 2023/01/29 19:10 | Michael Smith v Chris Dobey | 7-11 |
Away History
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/16 20:45 | Jonny Clayton v Chris Dobey | 6-1 |
| Players Championship 2 2023 | 2023/02/12 15:10 | Jonny Clayton v Steve Beaton | 6-1 |
| Players Championship 1 | 2023/02/11 17:35 | Ryan Searle v Jonny Clayton | 7-4 |
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/09 19:15 | Michael Smith v Jonny Clayton | 6-3 |
| Premier League Darts | 2023/02/02 19:15 | Dimitri van den Bergh v Jonny Clayton | 6-2 |
| The Masters 2023 | 2023/01/29 14:40 | Peter Wright v Jonny Clayton | 10-6 |
| The Masters 2023 | 2023/01/28 15:00 | Jonny Clayton v James Wade | 10-3 |
| Nordic Masters 2023 | 2023/01/21 19:10 | Gerwyn Price v Jonny Clayton | 11-10 |