Head to Head
| BDO World Championship 2019 | 2018/09/01 12:25 | Joe Cullen v Josh Payne | 6-4 |
Home History
| Players Championship 12 | 2023/05/21 16:05 | Andrew Gilding v Joe Cullen | 6-3 |
| Players Championship 11 2023 | 2023/05/20 16:10 | Joe Cullen v Radek Szaganski | 1-6 |
| Players Championship 11 2023 | 2023/05/20 15:20 | Ryan Joyce v Joe Cullen | 5-6 |
| European Tour 8 | 2023/05/13 19:10 | Joe Cullen v Karel Sedlacek | 4-6 |
| European Tour 7 | 2023/05/06 12:05 | Joe Cullen v Matthew Campbell | 3-6 |
| European Tour 6 | 2023/04/29 13:35 | Joe Cullen v Stephen Bunting | 5-6 |
| European Tour 5 | 2023/04/23 17:30 | Jonny Clayton v Joe Cullen | 6-3 |
| European Tour 5 | 2023/04/23 12:40 | Dirk van Duijvenbode v Joe Cullen | 2-6 |
Away History
| European Tour 9 2023 | 2023/05/26 20:25 | Josh Payne v Simon Whitlock | 6-3 |
| Players Championship 11 2023 | 2023/05/20 13:50 | Dave Chisnall v Josh Payne | 6-2 |
| Players Championship 11 2023 | 2023/05/20 12:30 | Nick Fullwell v Josh Payne | 3-6 |
| Players Championship 5 | 2023/03/11 14:25 | Karel Sedlacek v Josh Payne | 6-2 |
| UK Open 2023 | 2023/03/03 12:20 | Jelle Klaasen v Josh Payne | 6-2 |
| European Tour 1 2023 | 2023/02/24 15:35 | Bradley Brooks v Josh Payne | 6-2 |
| Players Championship 3 2023 | 2023/02/18 13:00 | Danny Noppert v Josh Payne | 6-2 |
| Players Championship 2 2023 | 2023/02/12 13:30 | Josh Payne v Ricky Evans | 6-2 |