Stadium: Macon Centreplex
| SPHL | 2023/12/24 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 7-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/23 00:00 | Macon Mayhem v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 1-6 |
| SPHL | 2023/11/26 21:00 | Macon Mayhem v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 0-1 |
| SPHL | 2023/11/19 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 3-2 |
| SPHL | 2023/02/26 21:00 | Macon Mayhem v Pensacola Ice Flyers | W | 7-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/01/22 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 4-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/01/21 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 5-2 |
| SPHL | 2023/01/16 22:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 7-1 |
| SPHL | 2024/01/01 01:00 | Evansville Thunderbolts v Macon Mayhem | W | 2-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/31 01:15 | Peoria Rivermen v Macon Mayhem | L | 5-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/30 01:15 | Peoria Rivermen v Macon Mayhem | L | 1-0 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/24 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | L | 7-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/23 00:00 | Macon Mayhem v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 1-6 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/16 23:30 | Macon Mayhem v Fayetteville Marksmen | L | 1-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/09 23:30 | Macon Mayhem v Knoxville Ice Bears | L | 1-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/09 00:00 | Macon Mayhem v Knoxville Ice Bears | L | 0-3 |
| SPHL | 2024/01/05 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Peoria Rivermen | L | 1-2 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/31 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Birmingham Bulls | L | 2-4 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/30 01:05 | Birmingham Bulls v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 4-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/27 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Birmingham Bulls | L | 2-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/24 01:05 | Pensacola Ice Flyers v Macon Mayhem | W | 7-3 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/23 00:00 | Macon Mayhem v Pensacola Ice Flyers | W | 1-6 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/17 01:00 | Huntsville Havoc v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 3-1 |
| SPHL | 2023/12/10 01:10 | Quad City Storm v Pensacola Ice Flyers | L | 5-3 |