Head to Head
| USA US Open Cup | 2018/05/07 00:00 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | L | 3-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/07/08 23:03 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | L | 1-0 |
Home History
| USA US Open Cup | 2018/05/07 00:00 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | L | 3-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2018/04/29 22:00 | Boston City FC v New York Cosmos II | W | 0-4 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/07/08 23:03 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | L | 1-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/05/25 23:27 | New York Cosmos II v TSF FC | W | 2-1 |
Away History
| USA US Open Cup | 2018/05/10 00:00 | Brooklyn Italians v Lansdowne Bhoys | L | 0-2 |
| USA US Open Cup | 2018/05/07 00:00 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | W | 3-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/07/08 23:03 | Brooklyn Italians v New York Cosmos II | W | 1-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/07/02 18:35 | Alexandria Rough Diamonds v Brooklyn Italians | W | 0-3 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/06/24 22:43 | Brooklyn Italians v Alexandria Rough Diamonds | W | 5-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2017/06/11 21:05 | Brooklyn Italians v Seacoast United Phantoms | W | 1-0 |
| USA US Open Cup | 2014/05/28 23:30 | New York Cosmos v Brooklyn Italians | L | 2-0 |