Head to Head
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/25 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Steel City | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2023/06/10 00:00 | Steel City v Erie Commodores | W | 2-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2023/05/26 23:00 | Erie Commodores v Steel City | W | 1-3 |
Home History
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/14 23:00 | Southern Indiana Guardians FC v Steel City | W | 0-5 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/08 23:00 | Steel City v SC Cleveland | W | 2-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/02 23:00 | Niagara 1812 v Steel City | W | 1-5 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/31 23:00 | Akron City v Steel City | W | 1-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/25 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Steel City | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/19 21:00 | Steel City v Flower City Union | W | 5-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/11 22:00 | Flower City Union v Steel City | W | 0-3 |
| USA US Open Cup | 2024/03/21 23:00 | Steel City v Michigan Stars | L | 0-1 |
Away History
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/21 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Southern Indiana Guardians FC | W | 7-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/14 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Niagara 1812 | W | 5-0 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/08 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Flower City Union | L | 2-3 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/06/02 22:00 | Michigan Rangers v Erie Commodores | L | 5-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2024/05/25 22:00 | Erie Commodores v Steel City | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2023/07/08 23:30 | Erie Commodores v Michigan Rangers | D | 1-1 |
| USA NPSL | 2023/06/30 23:00 | SC Cleveland v Erie Commodores | L | 3-2 |
| USA NPSL | 2023/06/24 23:00 | Carpathia FC v Erie Commodores | W | 3-5 |