Stadium: Maitland Federation Centre
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/05/21 03:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Maitland Mustangs | W | 79-81 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/04/01 08:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Hornsby Spiders | W | 96-64 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2021/05/08 09:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Hornsby Spiders | W | 95-81 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2019/07/13 09:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Hornsby Spiders | W | 81-68 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2019/04/13 07:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Maitland Mustangs | W | 83-96 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2018/07/07 08:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Hornsby Spiders | W | 89-63 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2017/07/01 07:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Maitland Mustangs | L | 94-93 |
| Australia Waratah League | 2017/05/21 03:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Hornsby Spiders | L | 85-86 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/20 09:00 | Sutherland Sharks v Maitland Mustangs | W | 82-85 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/13 09:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Canberra Gunners | W | 90-69 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/07 05:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Inner West Bulls | W | 101-79 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/06 08:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Newcastle Falcons | W | 109-72 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/08/12 07:00 | Maitland Mustangs v Sutherland Sharks | L | 80-83 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/08/05 09:30 | Canberra Gunners v Maitland Mustangs | W | 75-88 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/07/29 09:00 | Inner West Bulls v Maitland Mustangs | W | 81-92 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/07/22 09:00 | Albury Wodonga Bandits v Maitland Mustangs | L | 117-114 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/20 09:15 | Newcastle Falcons v Hornsby Spiders | L | 81-61 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/14 04:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Inner West Bulls | L | 87-104 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/13 07:00 | Manly Warringah Sea Eagles v Hornsby Spiders | L | 110-79 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/07 04:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Albury Wodonga Bandits | L | 82-91 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2024/04/06 08:00 | Central Coast Crusaders v Hornsby Spiders | L | 100-74 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/07/16 02:00 | Hornsby Spiders v Sydney Comets | L | 72-84 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/07/14 09:45 | Hornsby Spiders v Hills Hornets | L | 61-73 |
| Australia NBL1 East | 2023/07/08 08:00 | Manly Warringah Sea Eagles v Hornsby Spiders | W | 79-81 |