Head to Head
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/29 00:45 | Niall Culleton v John Henderson | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/28 22:25 | Niall Culleton v John Henderson | 2-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/27 22:55 | Niall Culleton v John Henderson | 0-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/27 00:05 | John Henderson v Niall Culleton | 2-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/25 10:25 | Niall Culleton v John Henderson | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 2023 | 2023/01/24 11:25 | Niall Culleton v John Henderson | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 12 | 2023/01/23 12:05 | John Henderson v Niall Culleton | 2-4 |
Home History
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 10:40 | Reece Robinson v Niall Culleton | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 09:55 | Niall Culleton v Gilbert van der Meijden | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 08:55 | Tommy Morris v Niall Culleton | 4-0 |
| Modus Super Series Week 4 | 2023/12/01 17:35 | Niall Culleton v Mat Caste | 4-3 |
| Modus Super Series Week 4 | 2023/12/01 16:40 | Cor Dekker v Niall Culleton | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 4 | 2023/12/01 15:45 | Danny Lauby v Niall Culleton | 4-0 |
| Modus Super Series Week 4 | 2023/12/01 14:30 | Niall Culleton v Stefan Bellmont | 4-3 |
| Modus Super Series Week 4 | 2023/12/01 13:05 | Scott Walters v Niall Culleton | 4-3 |
Away History
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 10:10 | John Henderson v Andreas Harrysson | 4-2 |
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 09:25 | John Henderson v Tommy Morris | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 3 | 2024/06/17 08:35 | Reece Robinson v John Henderson | 3-4 |
| World Seniors Champion of Champions 2024 | 2024/03/23 15:20 | John Henderson v Andy Hamilton | 8-10 |
| Players Championship 6 | 2024/03/19 14:10 | Michael van Gerwen v John Henderson | 6-3 |
| Players Championship 6 | 2024/03/19 13:10 | Callum Goffin v John Henderson | 1-6 |
| Players Championship 5 | 2024/03/18 14:30 | Lukas Wenig v John Henderson | 2-6 |
| UK Open 2024 | 2024/03/01 15:15 | Gian van Veen v John Henderson | 6-3 |