Stadium: Sherman Field Round: 1
| NCAAF | 2023/09/09 16:00 | Otterbein Cardinals v Muskingum Muskies | W | 14-27 |
| NCAAF | 2022/10/08 17:30 | Muskingum Muskies v Otterbein Cardinals | W | 41-35 |
| NCAAF | 2021/10/23 18:00 | Otterbein Cardinals v Muskingum Muskies | W | 14-31 |
| NCAAF | 2019/10/26 17:30 | Otterbein Cardinals v Muskingum Muskies | L | 18-10 |
| NCAAF | 2018/10/20 18:00 | Muskingum Muskies v Otterbein Cardinals | W | 21-14 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/07 17:30 | Mount St. Joseph Lions v Muskingum Muskies | W | 35-42 |
| NCAAF | 2023/11/11 18:30 | Marietta Pioneers v Muskingum Muskies | L | 21-20 |
| NCAAF | 2023/11/04 17:30 | Muskingum Muskies v Wilmington Quakers | W | 64-63 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/28 17:30 | John Carroll Blue Streaks v Muskingum Muskies | L | 42-13 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/21 18:00 | Muskingum Muskies v Ohio Northern Polar Bears | L | 17-27 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/14 23:00 | Muskingum Muskies v Baldwin Wallace Yellow Jackets | L | 22-34 |
| NCAAF | 2023/09/30 17:30 | Muskingum Muskies v Heidelberg Student Princes | L | 17-20 |
| NCAAF | 2023/09/23 17:30 | Mount Union v Muskingum Muskies | L | 74-7 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/07 22:00 | Ohio Wesleyan Battling Bishops v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 26-7 |
| NCAAF | 2023/11/11 18:30 | Otterbein Cardinals v John Carroll Blue Streaks | L | 22-37 |
| NCAAF | 2023/11/04 17:30 | Ohio Northern Polar Bears v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 49-6 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/28 17:30 | Mount Union v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 51-14 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/21 16:30 | Otterbein Cardinals v Baldwin Wallace Yellow Jackets | L | 0-24 |
| NCAAF | 2023/10/14 21:00 | Heidelberg Student Princes v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 28-8 |
| NCAAF | 2023/09/30 17:30 | Capital Crusaders v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 35-31 |
| NCAAF | 2023/09/23 17:30 | Marietta Pioneers v Otterbein Cardinals | L | 50-0 |