Round: 25 Ground: Hardcourt indoor
| Challenger Charlottesville Qual | 2016/10/30 14:00 | Eric Quigley v Aron Hiltzik | 5-7,6-2,5-7 |
| Challenger Champaign | 2016/11/15 17:55 | Eric Quigley v Brian Baker | 7-6,2-6,6-7 |
| Challenger Knoxville Qual | 2016/11/08 17:05 | Eric Quigley v Daniel Cox | 3-6,3-6 |
| Challenger Knoxville Qual | 2016/11/07 19:15 | Eric Quigley v Joe Salisbury | 6-2,7-6 |
| Challenger Charlottesville Qual | 2016/10/30 14:00 | Eric Quigley v Aron Hiltzik | 5-7,6-2,5-7 |
| Challenger Fairfield Qual | 2016/10/09 17:00 | Kevin Krawietz v Eric Quigley | 6-4,3-6,6-3 |
| Challenger Fairfield Qual | 2016/10/08 19:00 | John Lamble v Eric Quigley | 3-6,1-6 |
| Challenger Stockton Qual | 2016/10/02 18:20 | Eric Quigley v Dennis Nevolo | 2-6,4-6 |
| Challenger Stockton Qual | 2016/10/01 21:00 | James McGee v Eric Quigley | 2-6,1-6 |
| Challenger Columbus 2 Qual | 2016/11/21 17:15 | Luke Bambridge v Aron Hiltzik | 4-6,4-6 |
| Challenger Columbus 2 Qual | 2016/11/20 19:25 | Kyle Seelig v Aron Hiltzik | 3-6,3-6 |
| Challenger Columbus 2 Qual | 2016/11/19 18:45 | Alex Lawson v Aron Hiltzik | 7-5,4-6,3-6 |
| Challenger Champaign | 2016/11/15 01:15 | Tennys Sandgren v Aron Hiltzik | 6-1,6-2 |
| Challenger Charlottesville Qual | 2016/10/31 14:00 | Aron Hiltzik v Gonzales Austin | 7-5,5-7,6-7 |
| Challenger Charlottesville Qual | 2016/10/30 14:00 | Eric Quigley v Aron Hiltzik | 5-7,6-2,5-7 |
| Challenger Charlottesville Qual | 2016/10/29 17:40 | Roy Smith v Aron Hiltzik | 4-6,2-6 |
| ITF USA F31 | 2016/10/16 17:00 | Wil Spencer v Aron Hiltzik | 6-4,6-3 |