Stadium: Bison Stadium Round: 1
| NCAAF | 2023/09/16 17:00 | Thiel Tomcats v Bethany Bison | L | 22-14 |
| NCAAF | 2022/10/01 20:30 | Bethany Bison v Thiel Tomcats | L | 26-27 |
| NCAAF | 2021/10/09 20:30 | Bethany Bison v Thiel Tomcats | W | 28-7 |
| NCAAF | 2019/11/09 18:25 | Bethany Bison v Thiel Tomcats | W | 37-7 |
| NCAAF | 2018/11/03 17:00 | Thiel Tomcats v Bethany Bison | W | 0-20 |
| NCAAF | 2024/11/09 18:00 | St Vincent Bearcats v Bethany Bison | W | 13-21 |
| NCAAF | 2024/11/02 17:00 | Bethany Bison v Geneva Golden Tornadoes | L | 27-34 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/26 17:00 | Washington And Jefferson Presidents v Bethany Bison | L | 48-7 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/19 17:00 | Waynesburg Yellow Jackets v Bethany Bison | L | 34-14 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/12 20:30 | Bethany Bison v Westminster Titans | L | 7-49 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/05 17:00 | Bethany Bison v Grove City Wolverines | L | 22-62 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/21 23:00 | Carnegie Mellon Tartans v Bethany Bison | L | 66-0 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/14 23:00 | Case Western Reserve Spartans v Bethany Bison | L | 64-6 |
| NCAAF | 2024/11/09 18:00 | Waynesburg Yellow Jackets v Thiel Tomcats | L | 37-10 |
| NCAAF | 2024/11/02 17:00 | Thiel Tomcats v St Vincent Bearcats | W | 20-10 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/26 17:00 | Grove City Wolverines v Thiel Tomcats | L | 59-7 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/19 22:00 | Case Western Reserve Spartans v Thiel Tomcats | L | 52-7 |
| NCAAF | 2024/10/12 17:00 | Thiel Tomcats v Allegheny Gators | W | 21-7 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/28 19:00 | Thiel Tomcats v Westminster Titans | L | 6-58 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/21 23:00 | Geneva Golden Tornadoes v Thiel Tomcats | L | 21-6 |
| NCAAF | 2024/09/14 23:00 | Thiel Tomcats v Washington And Jefferson Presidents | L | 7-58 |