| NCAAB | 2013/02/09 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 70-55 |
| NCAAB | 2013/01/12 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 63-72 |
| NCAAB | 2012/02/04 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 58-59 |
| NCAAB | 2012/01/07 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 82-54 |
| NCAAB | 2011/03/02 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 69-53 |
| NCAAB | 2011/02/12 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 69-60 |
| NCAAB | 2011/01/15 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 57-66 |
| NCAAB | 2010/02/13 12:00 | Colgate v American | W | 75-74 |
| NCAAB | 2010/01/17 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 73-63 |
| NCAAB | 2009/02/14 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 69-44 |
| NCAAB | 2009/01/17 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 49-79 |
| NCAAB | 2008/03/14 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 52-46 |
| NCAAB | 2008/02/17 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 60-68 |
| NCAAB | 2008/01/19 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 65-57 |
| NCAAB | 2007/02/28 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 59-44 |
| NCAAB | 2007/02/11 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 58-64 |
| NCAAB | 2007/01/13 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 70-48 |
| NCAAB | 2006/02/12 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 72-64 |
| NCAAB | 2006/01/14 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 66-74 |
| NCAAB | 2005/02/13 12:00 | Colgate v American | W | 67-57 |
| NCAAB | 2005/01/30 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 78-59 |
| NCAAB | 2004/03/07 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 65-55 |
| NCAAB | 2004/02/22 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 65-62 |
| NCAAB | 2004/01/23 12:00 | Colgate v American | L | 71-74 |
| NCAAB | 2003/02/23 12:00 | Colgate v American | W | 60-59 |
| NCAAB | 2003/01/24 12:00 | American v Colgate | L | 58-55 |