Head to Head
| ECHL | 2021/11/13 00:15 | Toledo Walleye v Wheeling Nailers | L | 2-3 |
| ECHL | 2020/03/01 22:15 | Toledo Walleye v Wheeling Nailers | W | 6-0 |
| ECHL | 2020/01/12 22:15 | Toledo Walleye v Wheeling Nailers | L | 1-4 |
| ECHL | 2020/01/05 21:05 | Wheeling Nailers v Toledo Walleye | W | 1-8 |
| ECHL | 2019/12/28 00:15 | Toledo Walleye v Wheeling Nailers | W | 2-1 |
| ECHL | 2019/12/21 00:05 | Wheeling Nailers v Toledo Walleye | L | 3-0 |
| ECHL | 2019/12/08 21:05 | Wheeling Nailers v Toledo Walleye | W | 2-5 |
| ECHL | 2019/12/01 21:05 | Wheeling Nailers v Toledo Walleye | W | 4-5 |
| ECHL | 2019/11/06 15:35 | Toledo Walleye v Wheeling Nailers | W | 5-4 |