Stadium: Hinkle Fieldhouse Round: 1
Home Manager: LaVall Jordan Away Manager: Jerrod Calhoun
| NCAAB | 2012/02/09 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 59-68 |
| NCAAB | 2012/01/15 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 71-55 |
| NCAAB | 2011/02/03 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | W | 62-60 |
| NCAAB | 2011/01/09 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 84-79 |
| NCAAB | 2010/02/11 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 57-68 |
| NCAAB | 2010/01/16 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 91-61 |
| NCAAB | 2009/02/26 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 78-57 |
| NCAAB | 2008/12/06 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 71-79 |
| NCAAB | 2008/02/14 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 89-73 |
| NCAAB | 2008/01/19 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 69-78 |
| NCAAB | 2007/01/31 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 58-71 |
| NCAAB | 2007/01/17 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 67-39 |
| NCAAB | 2006/02/22 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 72-64 |
| NCAAB | 2006/01/21 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | W | 64-62 |
| NCAAB | 2005/02/23 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 59-79 |
| NCAAB | 2005/01/19 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 50-37 |
| NCAAB | 2004/03/02 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 88-57 |
| NCAAB | 2004/02/25 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 81-76 |
| NCAAB | 2004/01/21 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 66-67 |
| NCAAB | 2003/02/22 12:00 | Youngstown State v Butler | L | 60-69 |
| NCAAB | 2003/01/18 12:00 | Butler v Youngstown State | L | 64-60 |