Head to Head
| Italy Cup | 2023/02/26 15:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 8-12 |
| Italy A1 | 2022/12/07 14:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 14-8 |
| Italy A1 | 2022/03/26 11:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 7-5 |
| Italy A1 | 2022/01/09 11:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 3-13 |
| Champions League | 2021/03/04 19:15 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 10-3 |
| Champions League | 2020/12/15 19:15 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 7-10 |
| Italy A1 | 2020/02/01 14:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 12-18 |
| Italy A1 | 2019/05/11 13:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 19-1 |
| Italy Cup | 2019/03/09 14:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | D | 0-0 |
| Italy A1 | 2019/01/05 14:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 5-11 |
| Italy A1 | 2018/05/26 15:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 16-3 |
| Italy A1 | 2018/04/14 13:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 4-11 |
| Italy A1 | 2017/12/06 14:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 16-2 |
| Italy A1 | 2017/02/04 14:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 2-14 |
| Italy A1 | 2016/10/15 15:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 14-2 |
| Italy A1 | 2016/03/09 14:00 | Pro Recco v CC Ortigia | L | 18-6 |
| Italy A1 | 2015/11/07 14:00 | CC Ortigia v Pro Recco | L | 4-12 |