[11] New York City FC 1-3 FC Cincinnati [1] 2023-05-31 23:30
Stadium: Yankee Stadium
Referee: Armando Villarreal Home Manager: Nick Cushing Away Manager: Pat Noonan
Head to Head
| USA US Open Cup | 2023/05/10 23:00 | FC Cincinnati v New York City FC | L | 1-0 |
| USA MLS | 2022/09/08 00:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | D | 1-1 |
| USA MLS | 2022/06/29 23:30 | FC Cincinnati v New York City FC | D | 4-4 |
| USA MLS | 2021/09/18 23:30 | FC Cincinnati v New York City FC | W | 1-2 |
| USA MLS | 2021/04/24 17:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | W | 5-0 |
| USA MLS | 2020/09/26 23:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | W | 4-0 |
| USA MLS | 2020/09/12 23:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | W | 2-1 |
| USA MLS | 2019/08/17 23:30 | FC Cincinnati v New York City FC | W | 1-4 |
| USA MLS | 2019/06/06 23:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | W | 5-2 |
| Club Friendly List | 2016/02/24 22:00 | New York City FC v FC Cincinnati | L | 1-2 |