Stadium: Madison Square Garden Round: 3
Home Manager: Kevin Willard Away Manager: LaVall Jordan
| NCAAB | 2018/03/04 01:00 | Butler v Seton Hall | L | 70-77 |
| NCAAB | 2018/01/06 19:30 | Seton Hall v Butler | L | 90-87 |
| NCAAB | 2017/03/04 19:30 | Seton Hall v Butler | L | 70-64 |
| NCAAB | 2017/01/26 01:30 | Butler v Seton Hall | W | 61-54 |
| NCAAB | 2016/03/03 01:30 | Butler v Seton Hall | W | 85-78 |
| NCAAB | 2016/02/10 23:30 | Seton Hall v Butler | W | 75-81 |
| NCAAB | 2015/01/25 20:00 | Butler v Seton Hall | W | 77-57 |
| NCAAB | 2015/01/14 00:00 | Seton Hall v Butler | W | 75-79 |
| NCAAB | 2014/03/12 12:00 | Seton Hall v Butler | L | 51-50 |
| NCAAB | 2014/03/08 12:00 | Butler v Seton Hall | W | 71-54 |