Stadium: Growney Stadium Round: 1
| NCAAF | 2023/11/11 18:00 | Utica Pioneers v St John Fisher Cardinals | L | 14-0 |
| NCAAF | 2022/11/12 18:00 | St John Fisher Cardinals v Utica Pioneers | L | 21-35 |
| NCAAF | 2021/11/13 18:00 | Utica Pioneers v St John Fisher Cardinals | L | 35-14 |
| NCAAF | 2019/10/12 17:00 | Utica Pioneers v St John Fisher Cardinals | L | 34-28 |
| NCAAF | 2018/10/06 18:00 | Utica Pioneers v St John Fisher Cardinals | L | 33-7 |