| UFC Fight Night | 10/19 22:35 | - | Matheus Nicolau v Asu Almabaev | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 04/28 01:25 | - | Matheus Nicolau v Alex Perez | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 04/28 00:40 | - | Matheus Nicolau v Manel Kape | CANC | |
| UFC Fight Night | 01/14 01:00 | - | Matheus Nicolau v Manel Kape | CANC | |
| UFC Fight Night | 04/16 00:05 | - | Brandon Royval v Matheus Nicolau | 1-0 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 12/04 04:55 | - | Matheus Nicolau v Matt Schnell | 1-0 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 03/26 20:45 | - | David Dvorak v Matheus Nicolau | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 10/09 21:10 | - | Tim Elliott v Matheus Nicolau | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 03/14 01:30 | - | Manel Kape v Matheus Nicolau | 0-1 | |
| UFC Fight Night | 07/28 20:00 | - | Dustin Ortiz v Matheus Nicolau | 1-0 | |
| UFC | 12/31 01:00 | - | Louis Smolka v Matheus Nicolau | 0-1 |